CD Picks

Hall of Fame

  • Bands I've Seen Four Times or More:
    • Arcade Fire
    • Nicole Atkins & The Sea
    • Beck
    • Black Hollies
    • Bloc Party
    • Blur
    • Broken Social Scene
    • The Brunettes
    • Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
    • Death Cab for Cutie
    • The Decemberists
    • Doves
    • The Duke Spirit
    • Editors
    • Feist
    • Franz Ferdinand
    • French Kicks
    • Gorillaz
    • Grand National
    • The Grates
    • Immaculate Machine
    • Langhorne Slim
    • Les Sans Culottes
    • Love Is All
    • Kaiser Chiefs
    • Mates of State
    • Kate Nash
    • Neko Case
    • The New Pornographers
    • Northern State
    • Nouvellas
    • The Parlor Mob
    • Phoenix
    • The Pipettes
    • The Puppini Sisters
    • Radiohead
    • The Rakes
    • Ra Ra Riot
    • The Roots
    • Royksopp
    • Salt & Samovar
    • Secret Machines
    • The Shins
    • Sons & Daughters
    • Bruce Springsteen
    • Supergrass
    • They Might Be Giants
    • Tilly & The Wall
    • The Tings Tings
    • Vampire Weekend
    • Yeah Yeah Yeahs
    • Yo La Tengo

Guitar Pick Recipients

  • Recipients of the MusicSnobbery.com Guitar Pick
    • Damon Albarn
    • Nicole Atkins
    • Win Butler of Arcade Fire
    • Laura Cantrell
    • Sharin Foo of The Raveonettes
    • Inara George of The Bird & The Bee
    • Dave Hollinghurst of Nicole Atkins & The Sea
    • Ivan Howard of The Rosebuds
    • Dev Hynes of Lightspeed Champion
    • Sam Isaac
    • JayMay
    • Jay Jay Pistolet
    • Alex Kapranos of Franz Ferdinand
    • Langhorne Slim
    • Sondre Lerche
    • Emanuel Lundgren of I'm From Barcelona
    • Moby
    • David Moltz of Salt & Samovar
    • Peter Morén of Peter Bjorn & John
    • Keith Murray of We Are Scientists
    • Kate Nash
    • Carl Newman of The New Pornographers
    • Jack Peñate
    • Juanita Stein of Howling Bells
    • Anna Ternheim
    • Sune Rose Wagner of The Raveonettes
    • Katie White of The Ting Tings
    • Björn Yttling of Peter Bjorn & John

« Fastest 3 Minues in Music Blogging: RS 1000, Lily Allen, Spanish Techno Music and Why I'll Never Like RHCP | Main | The Walkmen's Hamilton Leithauser: The MusicSnobbery.com Interview »

May 19, 2006

Comments

Marysella

Man, I wish I would have been there. I tried to convince SOMEONE to come with me- sent out a mass email and all... NO ONE felt the excitement. Am I the only one I know that is willing to spend $100 on a good show? Note to self: find friends that can appreciate great music- and great food (that's a separate conversation). I even thought about getting a ticket and going dolo- but I didn't, after this article I regret it!!!!!!!!!! Specially that I ended up going to dinner and going to the movies for a movie marathon- dolo... I have seen the Roots, when I lived in DC and they gave me straight up goosebumps for about 3 hours- and I didn't even know all of their songs... I also filmed them for a DVD the Source was going to put out-they never did- in New Orleans. I experienced them first hand ON STAGE- talk about goosebumps. Great article.

Angela

I hope they'll do the reunion concert next year... sounds INCREDIBLE... nice to know that after all the drama that goes into getting all those musicians together to put together a performance of LIVE, INTERACTIVE music, ?uestLove feels 'accomplished' ; ) ~ and I know what you mean about Badu, too ~ she is a force to be reckoned with. proud, strong and TRUE. kinda like the music itself ~ be it hip hop, jazz, soul, funk, gospel, ROCK, and/or r&b... peace!

Ames

Thanks for this great review! You captured my experience completely. Though I'll admit I didn't rub shoulders with the crew like you did. Jealous!

Loved your review so much I name-checked it in mine. Check it out here at: http://blog.myspace.com/tixgirl

Gotty™

Very good coverage. Appreciate the report.

I'm sure you took a breath and realized that seeing all those cats rockin the stage had to be a once in a lifetime experience indeed.

Trevor

I was 3 rows behind you & I saw when Dave,Erykah & Mos came down the aisle(my battery on my camera had died by then DAMMIT)
you forgot Slum Village,who came on after Mos Def in tribute to the deceased J-Dilla. Hearring Mos sing the hook for SELFISH in place of Jonh Legend was awesome.And his enthusiasm was contageous.I enjoyed the show and look forward to seening the Roots again after Game Theory is released.

me

Great synopsis of the show! What a night I loved every frigging minute especially Dave Chappelle and of course Jay-Z. The crowd went wild when he took off his hoodie. I had to see the show because I love Questlove -- he is the best drummer of all time. I ran into the same problem as Marysella --- I couldn't talk any of my lame friends into going to the show and by the time I went to purchase my tickets I was able to purchase ONE ticket on the floor so I took a leap of faith and bought one. I almost lost my courage the day of the show but I said "what the hay," got dressed and drove myself to Radio City Music Hall. Damn, I'm glad I went because the show was truly history in the making. Lesson from the night, Jay-Z is godlike and it pays to take a risk. Peace.

atm

Thursday's show was teh suck, so you can thank your spidey-sense on that also.

Quest rambles about it on his MySpace blog and I would link to it but I'm lazy, so go find it

rbz

Thanks for the in-depth review...I was there too and the show was all you described and more...don't mean to be rude (nothing but love for those who feel how I feel about my Roots crew), but just wanted to point out that the Roots got together in 1989, not the mid-'90s. That makes it SEVENTEEN years together and they're just getting to where they belong...to be recognized as MASTERS of their game. LONG LIVE THE ROOTS!!!

MusicSnobbery

Many thanks for stopping by, gang. Big traffic over the weekend, thanks for to ?uestlove for his linkage.

I must admit I don't know who Slum Village was when they got on stage. It was my chance to run to the bathroom. Shhhhhh, don't tell.

Matt Berlyant

Great review! I wish that I would've gotten tickets! When I saw them in Philadelphia last September(my review can be found here:
http://japanesegodjesusrobot.blogspot.com/2005/09/what-they-do.html) they also made a similar entrance (and exit) with a New Orleans brass band accompanying them. The concert was a benefit for Hurricane Katrina vicitims, so it was fitting and quite moving.

pwc

wasnt this supposed to be a Dilla tribute?

pwc

wow you dont know who slum is WTF!? at a Dilla tribute, you don't know who slum is, thats waaaaaaaaack do the knowledge....pleeeeeeeaaaaaasssseeeee

So Live Arts Movement

Well, I must say that from the moment that The Roots came in with a martching band I was completly floored. I was originally supprosed to go by myslef knowing htat I would meet people along the way. My friend told me at the last minuite that she wanted to go... So we were on our quest to find better seats and sit together. WE almost got ripped off by this insistant dude from Miami, but luckily they were sellin tickets for 10th row center the day of the show for $70. And I sold my ticket right away for the same price, God is good.

That show was amazing, but nothing could top that encore with Jay Z I nearly feel out of my seat.

peace.al-b

CB Slave

My gf and I were supposed to go - she was running late - so I left w/o her.

I'm SOO glad I did. I would have been very close to 1st degree murder if I missed the show cause she held me up. Everything that night was on point...barring J Davey (not really my speed). I didn't even mind the clouds of purple haze floating above me during the show.

It was one of those moments in the history of hip-hop and music that will go down and the best of the best.

I was floored.

Okay - back to the cotton field I go.

KP

I did not appreciate your comment about Radiohead not being played on Hot97, your comment was very stereotypical. If you knew anything about true fans of the Roots you would never make a comment like that. True Roots fans are lovers of music, alot of different music, that is why we can appreciate the roots; because of their versatility, craft, and genuine appreciation for music. For you to assume that you were the only one in the audiance who knew that they were doing a tribute to Radiohead is a little jarring. You stated: "Just the idea is astonishing, hip-hop guys with a R&B singer, covering the most highly-regarded British rock band of our times." Why is it so astonishing Mr. Music Snob? The Roots and Bilal are not just some hip-hop guys and some singer, the Roots may be; if not equally, more reknown than Radiohead. Oh and for the record, they don't even play on Hot97.

Tom Huggz

Man that sounded like an amazing show, The roots with bilal covering radiohead....fuck! We don't get anything like that down here in Australia, buthey I'm seeing the roots 2 times in a week in april, I'm hoping for the goods.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment