CD Picks

Hall of Fame

  • Bands I've Seen Four Times or More:
    • Arcade Fire
    • Nicole Atkins & The Sea
    • Beck
    • Black Hollies
    • Bloc Party
    • Blur
    • Broken Social Scene
    • The Brunettes
    • Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
    • Death Cab for Cutie
    • The Decemberists
    • Doves
    • The Duke Spirit
    • Editors
    • Feist
    • Franz Ferdinand
    • French Kicks
    • Gorillaz
    • Grand National
    • The Grates
    • Immaculate Machine
    • Langhorne Slim
    • Les Sans Culottes
    • Love Is All
    • Kaiser Chiefs
    • Mates of State
    • Kate Nash
    • Neko Case
    • The New Pornographers
    • Northern State
    • Nouvellas
    • The Parlor Mob
    • Phoenix
    • The Pipettes
    • The Puppini Sisters
    • Radiohead
    • The Rakes
    • Ra Ra Riot
    • The Roots
    • Royksopp
    • Salt & Samovar
    • Secret Machines
    • The Shins
    • Sons & Daughters
    • Bruce Springsteen
    • Supergrass
    • They Might Be Giants
    • Tilly & The Wall
    • The Tings Tings
    • Vampire Weekend
    • Yeah Yeah Yeahs
    • Yo La Tengo

Guitar Pick Recipients

  • Recipients of the MusicSnobbery.com Guitar Pick
    • Damon Albarn
    • Nicole Atkins
    • Win Butler of Arcade Fire
    • Laura Cantrell
    • Sharin Foo of The Raveonettes
    • Inara George of The Bird & The Bee
    • Dave Hollinghurst of Nicole Atkins & The Sea
    • Ivan Howard of The Rosebuds
    • Dev Hynes of Lightspeed Champion
    • Sam Isaac
    • JayMay
    • Jay Jay Pistolet
    • Alex Kapranos of Franz Ferdinand
    • Langhorne Slim
    • Sondre Lerche
    • Emanuel Lundgren of I'm From Barcelona
    • Moby
    • David Moltz of Salt & Samovar
    • Peter Morén of Peter Bjorn & John
    • Keith Murray of We Are Scientists
    • Kate Nash
    • Carl Newman of The New Pornographers
    • Jack Peñate
    • Juanita Stein of Howling Bells
    • Anna Ternheim
    • Sune Rose Wagner of The Raveonettes
    • Katie White of The Ting Tings
    • Björn Yttling of Peter Bjorn & John

« VV Brown's Album Gets U.S. Release Dates | Main | Longwave / The Grates @ Bowery Ballroom »

November 16, 2009

Comments

CB in NJ

I thought the show was rather strange and strained. I've never seen her before, but I'm not used to the headliner having a band member do the intros and being the liaison with the audience. Neko is a witty and sharp individual, but no of that came through on stage. And of course once you get shocked by electricity you get shakened up and are very leary of your surroundings, but a little explaination about the no encore would be helpful. I left feeling somewhat unsatisfied by her show.

CB in NJ

Was there a bit of irony with the photo you posted of Neko- her guitar strap has a lightning bolt on it.

PD

I echo CB's comment. Some explanation was in order, even if it came from another band member. Without an explanation Neko left a passionate audience dumbfounded. And if it was related to the shocks she sustained, all the more reason to say so. We would have respected her professionalism and grit to continue another 45 minutes or so. Instead, we're wondering if she just didn't want to waste any more of her talent on this audience.

Suzy

I was also a bit shocked by the early exit. I timed it closer to 60 minutes, not 75.

PM

I think it was all related to the comment when she was putting on her sweater. It sounded like the person said no, but she heard it as GO (meaning hurry up and play something). She told him something like get your own band and then you can GO! She was joking around about the shocks before the sweater thing. After the exchange with the person in the crowd, she didn't say another thing, quickly went through a few more songs and left. Professionalism.... that's a joke, learn how to deal with a heckler and don't punish the rest of the crowd.

PD

PM -- I thought that may have been the case as well. I guess we'll never know. I'd like to believe otherwise (as in my previous post), but her demeanor from that point on was much different. I thought maybe the effects from the shocks may have taken their toll, but she certainly overreacted to that comment (whether it was No or GO). And leaving the stage with just a flip little wave (I did not hear her say goodnight) was somewhat telling.

Charlie Brownfield

Case is tremendously talented as singer and a songwriter (and even has talent as a visual artist). But given her lyrcis and how she presents herself in interviews and on her website, I'd hardly expect her to be "nice" person in the Montclair way, and I can't imagine she gives a @#$^@$ whether people thought her show was too short. I saw the show, and to paraphrase Morrissey I love her only slightly, only slightly less than I did before.

Laura in NJ

I wasn't at the Wellmont show, but she hit a home run at last night's Beacon show. Played from 9:15 til nearly 11:00, and not only did an encore, but it consisted of FOUR songs. She looked positively smashing in a (new, she said) ruby red jewel-toned silk dress and strappy mary jane pumps for grownup girls. And yes, she was in a great mood.

I am still a fan.

PD

Figures. She vamps it up for the big time NYC gig but rolls out of bed with curlers for the NJ show. She ain't no Joe DiMaggio, who gave 100 percent effort every game because he believed someone in the stands might be watching him play for the first time. We are measured by the way we treat those who can do little or nothing for us. She comes up short.

SB

It isn't the fault of the rest of the people who paid to see her, but if I had been shocked and heckled in front of a theater full of people I might be inclined to get the hell out too. I've been to several shows where there was no encore and I only felt cheated once (and by a band who obviously phoned in the entire performance).

Not to rub it in, but Laura is right: Neko kicked ass at the Beacon. The voice, the hair, that dress... Still buzzing here.

PD

No excuse for leaving the stage without even a good night and thanks for coming. None.

laslo

I was really really sad after the show, and hurt that she'd left so abruptly. I understood the mic thing, but things didn't really seem to go downhill after the heckler. why punish a room full of breathlessly devoted fans because of one stupid jerk?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment